
You gotta tell yourself with these things, it's an adaptation, not a straight translation to another medium. "Hey, you turn nearly 400 pages into a 90 minute film and you're going to have to lose some things."
Unfortunately, just about everything not directly related to the main plot is gone, and it didn't even get a full 90 minutes. Much of the foreshadowing and subplots, and unfortunately very nearly all the subtlety of the original work is gone, which really weakens the piece. The strength of the comic was in the world Cooke had created and how these extraordinary people found their place in it as heroes, and unfortunately we just don't see that world here. That reduces it to a good sci-fi movie (with some dashes of noir here and there) that turns into a good action movie, but not something with even half the depth or nearly so engrossing as the comic.
The voice acting varies. It's a great cast, but unfortunately many of them seem to not be used to voice acting, uncomfortable with it, or just plain not so good at it. None of it is bad, it just feels a bit stiff from a lot of characters. J'Onn is the best performance, and Lois' (small part as it is) is quite good as well. Batman's is above average for this film; the performances for Superman, Faraday, Wonder Woman, Hal Jordan and Flash are all uneven. Oh, Carol Ferris is very good as well.
The look is interesting. It's not quite Cooke, but more like Cooke designs filtered and simplified through Timm's previous DC work. (That's likely not what happened, but that's what it looks like to me.) The colors are very clean; sharp and bright but flat, and that really makes it look like the Dini/Timm animated DCU. I was expecting much darker and much closer to the comic. The animation is
gorgeous; the best we've seen yet from the WB on the DC properties.
I also want to mention the opening sequence, the prologue, it's just a beautiful piece of work.
On its own, not holding it to the book, it's quite good. Much, much better than Superman: Doomsday. I just made the mistake of watching right after reading the comic, so I kept seeing what wasn't there instead of being able to focus on what was. I really do recommend you check it out. I hope the next direct to video DC feature is as good.
Oh, and while I'm posting; do you guys want these kinds of serious reviews? Or would you rather stick to the ones like I did for
Steel where I just make some lame comment?